Return printed form to:

Jeff Buchanan
English Department
Youngstown State University
One University Plaza
Youngstown, OH 44555

or email to:
jmbuchanan@ysu.edu

OJELA Reviewer Comment Form
Reviewers: Your comments are crucial to decisions about publishing these manuscripts. Please provide details describing the strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript. Your comments will be sent to the editors and the authors. Phrase comments in a respectful and reflective manner.

Reviewer's Form - this form can be filled out, saved and emailed.

The above listed form may be completed online, saved and emailed. You can open the form and use it for the manuscript you are reviewing now or save the form as a template and use it each time you are sent a manuscript. As you fill in your selections or comments, the grey boxes will expand.  Once you complete the form, assign the form a unique name i.e. Manuscript 48.1:01 and save it to a folder or your desktop.  If you do not rename the file, you cannot use it as a blank template for future reviews. Make sure you keep the .doc extension. Once the form is saved, attach it to an email addressed to jmbuchanan@ysu.edu.  It works most reliably in Internet Explorer 5 and above.